« Call for Real Estate Consumer Bill of Rights expanding? | Main | All Saints' Day debate: Should sellers bury St. Joseph statues? »

October 31, 2007

Misleading medians understate savings opportunities for homebuyers

Surprising_bubblestats1 Posted in response to blog post entitled "Boston Housing Prices" on Boston.com's new real estate blog, Boston Real Estate Now:

As some of your readers know, focusing on median sales prices can understate the magnitude of saving opportunities in the housing market.  Like the image above, a closer look at sales behind the housing bubble reveals some surprising findings!  If, for example, you focus on sales of single family homes in the 28 most expensive suburban communities in Greater Boston last month (Sept. 2007), these findings emerge from the MLS:

1.  Sales were down nearly one third from last year:  216 sales in 9/07 versus 300 sales in 9/06;

2.  The percent of homes selling below their assessed value, once unthinkable in Greater Boston, rose slightly from 37% in 9/06 to 40% in 9/07;

3.  Those who argue that prices are holding up in Greater Boston can point to these stats: 

3.1  Twelve listings sold for over  their original asking price or 1 in 20 listings;

3.2  Another 13 listings sold for their original asking price or 1 in 20 again;

4.  In contrast, those who argue that median statistics are misleading would point to these stats:

4.1  One in four listings, or 53 of 216 single family homes in the most expensive suburban communities, sold for at least $99,000 less than the original asking price -- a trend we mapped last year;

5.  Looking just at the 86 homes which sold below their assessed value, 1 in 3 sold for at least $99,000 off;

6.  Switching from dollars saved to percent saved last month:

6.  One in three listings sold for at least 10% less than their original asking price; and worse

7.  One in ten sold for at least 17% below than their original asking price!

So, if you are a buyer, don't be too quick to base your assessment of market value, and hence your offer, on median sales prices or market indexes which are showing modest declines.  Historically, one in five homes which go under agreement between Thanksgiving and New Years, sell for at least 10% below the original asking price.  As the statistics above reveal, price reductions are likely to be deeper and more wide spread this year.  We'll map them on our award-winning real estate bubble map. It's an open, interactive map so Real Estate Cafe clients can earn rebate bonuses by adding properties, too.

Bill Wendel | 11:42 AM in Bubble map, Defensive Homebuying, Market trends, Price trends, Savings & Rebates, Timing the market | Permalink


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Misleading medians understate savings opportunities for homebuyers:


NOTE: Your email address will not be published on this page with your comment. Followup to your comment will generally appear here. Occassionally the Real Estate Cafe may use your email address to followup with you directly however it is not shared or given to anyone else nor added to a RE Cafe mailing list.

So, you are saying this is a "great time to buy"? Are you a real estate agent? ;)
"Apprised value"? Haven't you read the result of anounimous poll of apprisers that said 80% of them have/had pressure from real estate gang to apprise properties "in the right way"?
"Saving opportunities"? What are you talking about?
Many serious economists say that we are just in the beginning of huge price drop.
It's like suggesting people to buy Internet stocks right before they fell!
Enough simple minds are still buying now listening to real estate gang chants "Buy now until it's too late" and cheering tiny price drop from completely rediculous level!
You want to lure more people in financial hole?

Posted by: Booba | Nov 1, 2007 12:32:02 PM

Another great post. Keep up the good work.

The MLS and other sources are full of useful real estate market data. Real estate brokers just have to want to do the work and use it on behalf of their clients.

Posted by: Rich Rosa | Nov 9, 2007 7:57:01 PM

The comments to this entry are closed.